You must find at least 4 different point of care test devices from different companies and compare these devices in 15 different criteria such as, type of sample, accuracy, size…etc. and you must write these information in excel sheet.
Then you must chose only one best device:
Provide justification for your choice of device:
To do this you will need to develop a selection criteria to compare the available devices. Then you will need to summarise your recommendations and consider any on-going operational procedures required in order to provide quality results for patient testing.
Include in your answer recommendations with regard to:
• Critical evaluation of testing devices which provide results appropriate to clinical requirements (i.e. is the chosen device fit for purpose ?)
• Pre-analytical considerations
o Instructions for patient preparation and sample collection
o Patient safety and risk management
o Operator handling & training required
• Analytical considerations
o Frequency and type of quality control (QC)
o External quality assessment (EQA) procedures
o Device maintenance requirements
• Post-analytical o Instructions for the recording / reporting of results
• Other general considerations for testing
Some background notes about this assignment:
For the successful completion of this exercise, you will need to think about all the aspects of testing for these analytes. This will include all of the quality specifications as well as the practical considerations such as user friendliness, cost, shelf-life of reagents, portability and so forth. (Note: This is what you would need to do in a work environment if you were asked to select a new instrument – be it lab or POCT). To do this you would first collate the data and include it in a spreadsheet for comparison. Then once your comparison and decision is made, you would write a brief report for your manager. Such a R. Greaves POCT Page 2 report is called an executive summary. This summary is only one page in length – this is because your manager is busy and just wants your conclusions with brief justifications.
Justification = Excel spread sheet: Develop a spreadsheet for your justification and embed it as a linked table in the word document). This spreadsheet should critically compare devices against your selection criteria.
Recommendations = Written (executive) summary: Provide a written summary justifying your recommendations. Make sure you justify your summary using the evidence from your Excel sheet. As this is an executive summary, your text should be no more than one page of writing with a word limit of 250 for the written text.
Referencing: Vancouver style. Place your relevant references at the bottom of your Excel sheet and just add the main references based on your decision to the word document.